ECB under fire for handling of downturn
By Ralph Atkins in Frankfurt
Published: August 25 2008 16:58 | Last updated: August 25 2008 23:16
Europeans are scathing about their governments’ responses to the economic downturn across the continent, but the European Central Bank faces greater public criticism for its handling of the crisis than the Bank of England.
Most of those in the main European countries who thought the economy had worsened laid much of the responsibility at the door of their governments, according to the latest Financial Times/Harris opinion poll.
Most blamed was Berlin, with 74 per cent of Germans saying their government held “complete†or “a lot of†responsibility. London – at 63 per cent – fared slightly better, in spite of the problems faced by Gordon Brown, UK prime minister. But in Spain, which like the UK has been hit by a serious housing market correction, the figure was only 53 per cent.
When asked how governments had handled the economic downturn and its consequences, Berlin also fared worse than London, with 88 per cent of Germans describing their government’s handling as “bad†or “terrible,†compared with 71 per cent in the UK. The relatively high level of German disgruntlement is hard to explain given that, until recently, Europe’s largest economy had appeared relatively resilient in the face of global economic storms.
Differences between the UK and continental Europe were arguably starker, however, when those polled were asked about central banks’ actions. The Bank of England ran into a political storm over the handling of Northern Rock, the stricken mortgage lender, but it has scored higher marks from the public than its Frankfurt-based counterpart.
Some 23 per cent of those in Britain who said the economy had worsened agreed that the Bank of England had acted appropriately to the challenges of the economic downturn, with 37 per cent disagreeing.
When it came to the ECB, only 5 per cent of the Spanish and 8 per cent of Germans were prepared to say it had responded appropriately to deteriorating economic conditions, with 56 and 48 per cent disagreeing. Spanish discontent could reflect the fact the ECB has raised its main interest rate over the past year, in spite of the abrupt slowdown in Spain’s economy and the financial pressures facing many homeowners.
German dismay is harder to explain, especially as the ECB won praise in financial markets for its early and bold injections of emergency liquidity at the start of the crisis.
Another surprising result is that in France – where political criticism of the ECB has been loudest – the Frankfurt institution appears to enjoy slightly better public support than in Germany, Spain or Italy. In the US, the Federal Reserve also fared worse than the Bank of England.
Another trend to emerge from the survey is the sweeping changes to Europeans’ behaviour that have resulted from higher inflation and the credit squeeze. Some 25 per cent of Italians, 24 per cent of Americans, and 23 per cent of the British said that their lifestyles had changed “completely†or “a lot†as a result. The figures for Germany, Spain and France were only slightly lower.
Most commonly, those polled said they had made fewer visits to restaurants, pubs and cinemas, cut food bills and delayed the purchases of new clothes and consumer goods. Surprisingly, given the steep increase in petrol prices, there appeared to be a greater reluctance to drive cars less or switch to public transport – perhaps reflecting a view that driving a car is a necessity rather than a luxury. Only about a third of the French and Germans polls said they were driving their cars less, and only 22 per cent in the UK.
The Germans and Spanish were the most likely to have delayed purchasing a new car, with the British the least likely.
The FT/Harris poll was conducted online between July 30 and August 12 among 6,134 adults in France, Germany, Great Britain, Spain, Italy and the US.
◠Higher inflation and the credit squeeze have led to sweeping changes in Europeans’ behaviour, the FT/Harris Poll has found.
Some 25 per cent of Italians and 23 per cent of Britons said that their lifestyles had changed “completely†or “a lotâ€. The figures for Germany, Spain and France were only slightly lower.
Most commonly, those polled said they had made fewer visits to restaurants, pubs and cinemas, cut food bills and delayed buying new clothes and consumer goods. Discount stores are also becoming more popular, with 49 per cent of Britons and 66 per cent of Germans shopping at them more often.
Given the steep increase in petrol prices, there were some signs that people were driving cars less or switching to public transport. About a third of the French and Germans polled and 22 per cent in the UK said they were driving less.
The Germans and Spanish were the most likely to have delayed the purchase of a new car, with the British the least likely.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008