by winston » Fri Nov 26, 2021 9:23 am
CHINA PROPERTY – SLOWLY CLIMBING THE WALL OF WORRY
The MSCI China Real Estate Index has underperformed the MSCI China Index YTD, given concerns over China Evergrande’s liquidity issues, continued regulatory headwinds facing the property sector and talks of imminent pilot property tax reforms.
However, since late Sep, we have started to see incremental positives, including supportive commentary from senior government officials and marginal policy easing.
This has helped to provide some boost to mortgage loans growth and bond issuances by selective developers.
However, one key overhang for the sector stems from pilot property tax reforms, which will be introduced to more cities given President Xi’s drive for “common prosperity” in the nation.
Uncertainties over the timing, tax rates and implementation has dampened consumer sentiment, which will continue to exert downward pressure on residential sales.
This has also been reflected in declines in the contracted sales of Chinese developers.
On a positive note, we note that over the past few months, there have been more Chinese property developers which have seen their ESG ratings being upgraded, such as China Resources Land, CIFI Group, Logan and Longfor.
This is certainly an encouraging sign and reflects the growing importance which the property sector is placing on environmental, social and corporate governance factors in their business operations.
Using the MSCI China Real Estate Index as a benchmark, valuations are unsurprisingly at cheap levels given the headwinds faced.
The MSCI China Real Estate Index is trading at a forward price-to-earnings (P/E) and price-to-book (P/B) ratio of 5.0x and 0.70x (as at 24 Nov 2021).
This is 0.8 and 1.5 standard deviations (s.d.) below their respective 5-year averages of 6.0x and 0.97x.
From a dividend standpoint, the forward dividend yield stood at 6.2%, which is 0.3 s.d. above the 5-year average of 5.9%.
We had highlighted in our previous report on 17 Sep 2021 titled “Expectations reset” that we did see selective buying opportunities in good quality developers with healthy balance sheets and an increasing ESG focus.
Since then, we have seen incrementally positive developments in the industry as what we have discussed in this report.
However, as volatile market conditions are likely to stay, we maintain our stance on being selective, and would urge a prudent and gradual approach in building up positions.
We keep Longfor Group (960 HK), China Resources Land (CR Land) (1109 HK), China Overseas Land & Investment (COLI) (688 HK) and Country Garden Services (6098 HK) as our preferred Chinese property picks.
Their share prices have rebounded 22%, 28%, 14% and 2% respectively, since our report in Sep.
On the other hand, we remain ‘Sell-rated’ on highly leveraged names such as China Evergrande (3333 HK) and Guangzhou R&F (2777 HK) and opine that they will continue to face difficulties in refinancing their debt, while future growth prospects have been severely hampered as they would have to divest their assets (especially their quality ones) and tighten their purse strings.
China property sector has unsurprisingly underperformed YTD
Seeing incremental positives within industry, but overall policy tightness and uncertainties likely to stay
Stick with quality; preferred BUYs: 960 HK, 1109 HK, 688 HK, 6098 HK; preferred SELLs: 3333 HK, 2777 HK
Source: OCBC
It's all about "how much you made when you were right" & "how little you lost when you were wrong"