by winston » Wed Dec 23, 2009 5:04 pm
Not vested. From Lim & Tan:-
NOBLE GROUP
Serving Rising Needs Of China & India S$3.01-NOBL.SI
Noble has proposed the following disposals to Macarthur Coal of Australia:
- 87.7% stake (71,902,868 shares) in Gloucester Coal by accepting Macarthur’s offer of 0.84 Macarthur share per Gloucester share, valuing the stake at A$586.3 mln or A$8.16 each, based on Macarthur’s A$9.71 close. Noble will receive 60,398,409 Macarthur shares or 17% of the latter’s enlarged capital. (There is a cash option of A$8
per Gloucester share.)
- 79.9% stake (255.68mln shares) in Donaldson Coal for A$185.8 mln to be satisfied by a
combination of A$48 mln cash and 14.21 mln Macarthur shares.
- 25.34% stake (81,450 shares) in Middlemount Coal for A$207.5 mln, A$127 mln cash and 8.29 mln Macarthur shares. (Middlemount is a JV between Noble and Macarthur.)
Noble will end up with a 24% stake (82,903,564 shares) in the much-bigger MacArthur Coal (indeed, the largest independent coal producer in Australia), which has a
market cap of A$2484.5 mln yesterday. While Gloucester operates the Stratford and Duralie mines, which produce coking and thermal coal, in New South Wales, Macarthur operates the Coppabella and Mooorvale mines in the Bowen Basin in Queensland,
which produce the low volatile PCI coal.
The above transactions are subject to a series of conditions by Feb 28’2010, eg approval by Australia’s Foreign Investment Review Board, the Gloucester offer becoming unconditional, approval from shareholders of Macarthur etc.
Comments
1. We believe the proposed transactions are positive for Noble (as well as Macarthur as evidenced by the market reaction this morning).
2. The combined book value of Noble’s stakes in Gloucester, Donaldson and Middlemount adds up to US$723.292 mln, vs US$821.6 mln for the Macarthur shares it will receive. However, the combined net profits before tax of US$52.158 mln is US$4.88 mln above US$47.28 mln attributed to the Macarthur shares.
3. The transactions are also positive in that:
- They increase Noble’s exposure to coal mining / production in Australia, an important supplier of coal to China and India.
- They help reduce Noble’s dependence on the highly volatile trading activities, and raise exposure to actual producing assets, which are in keeping with the Glencore model.
As Noble’s COO said the transactions “validate the importance we place on adding value at all stages of the supply chain for key commodities in which we tradeâ€.
- We believe having China Investment Corp (CIC) as a substantial shareholder helps.
- It is worth noting the 3 substantial shareholders of Macarthur: Citic Resources of China with a 22.4% stake currently (16.9% after); Arcelor Mittal with 16.6% (12.52%) and Posco of South Korea, with 8.3% (6.3%).
4. Although Noble had recently slightly exceeded our target of $3.20, hitting intra-day high of $3.26 on Dec 9th, we believe there is further upside, now that we are seeing
benefits of the CIC connection coming through.
5. We therefore maintain BUY, especially if the current weakness in commodities, as a direct result of the strengthening US$, continues.
It's all about "how much you made when you were right" & "how little you lost when you were wrong"