by winston » Tue Feb 24, 2009 4:49 pm
BUY OR SELL-Are chip foundries a bargain after sell-off?
* foundry shares at multi-year lows as tech sales slump
* little sign of near-term recovery in demand
* bigger is better - TSMC favoured by most analysts
By Baker Li TAIPEI, Feb 24 (Reuters) - Major chip foundries are sharing the pain of the semiconductor sector's worst ever downturn and, with little sign of near-term recovery in demand for computers, mobile phones and flat-screen TVs, investors have punished foundry shares across the board.
In Taipei, shares of market leader Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co Ltd (TSMC) <2330.TW> hit their lowest level in more than five years in late 2008 and have been rangebound since then. United Microelectronics Corp (UMC) <2303.TW> hovers at lows not seen since 1994.
Singapore's Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing struggles near record lows.
TSMC FAVOURED Despite the gloom, some see the downturn as a good buying opportunity, especially for cash-rich chip makers that can afford to invest in more advanced and efficient technology in the downturn.
Their extra resources now could give them an edge in the next upturn over smaller peers struggling just to stay in business.
"Only TSMC will be profitable this year, and it won't be a recovery across the whole foundry market," said Nomura semiconductor analyst Rick Hsu, who rates TSMC a buy.
"On the advanced technology side, there's a gap between TSMC and other smaller players. TSMC has been taking a front seat in driving technology to more advanced notes," Hsu said.
"UMC has been playing catch-up but the problem is how it can get more new orders when TSMC has a wider customer base." Contract chip makers supply chip designers without facilities and other clients that have their own plants but are increasingly outsourcing production to focus on design and marketing.
Unlike memory chips, where one maker's chip is similar to another's, logic chip foundries require higher technology and marketing to meet demands from clients such as Texas Instruments and Nvidia , whose sales depend on quality chips.
Based on a price-to-book ratio of 2.8 this year, Nomura put TSMC's target share price at T$53, implying 20 percent upside from Tuesday's close of T$44.00.
In the past month, eight of 13 analysts have rated TSMC shares "buy" or "outperform", while only two gave the stock a "sell" or "underperform" rating, according to Reuters data.
TSMC had cash and marketable securities totalling T$211.5 billion ($6.1 billion) at the end of 2008.
"TSMC still has a lot of cash on its hands so it has the ability to move up the tech ladder in the future. We already jumped to buy when the stock dipped to T$38 late last year," said Michael On, managing director of Beyond Asset Management.
"The big will become bigger, so it should be tough for those second-tier companies and maybe they will be gone some day." TSMC Chairman and founder Morris Chang said this week the sector could be near bottom, though he added the recovery could be slow. [ID:nnTP224728] L-SHAPED RECOVERY Some say a long winter for the sector is just beginning after three of the industry's top four players recently reported big fourth-quarter losses and TSMC predicted it would post its first loss since 1990 in the current quarter.
"Customers had been adjusting inventories since late last year and it will be just an L-shape recovery, said Eddie Chen, vice president at National Investment Trust.
"We don't expect any strong recovery by the end of the second quarter, so it is not the right time to buy now since global financial risks still exist." Deutsche Bank has downgraded its rating on Chartered to "sell" from "buy" on fears that tier-two foundries would more rapidly lose market share to TSMC.
Globally TSMC had a 65 percent share of the foundry market in 2008, and its market share would rise to 69 percent in 2010, while UMC, Chartered Semi and China's SMIC <0981.HK> would take the remaining 31 percent together, according to Deutsche Bank.
Karen Lin, a fund manager at Paradigm Asset Management Co Ltd, said sentiment has improved somewhat recently due to some rush orders.
"But there's no rush to increase your holdings," she said.
"You'd better wait until after April and see if demand really picks up. There are still some uncertainties." "If you really want to buy foundry stocks during this downturn but don't want to worry too much in the longer term, your choice will be the most competitive company, that is TSMC," she said.
It's all about "how much you made when you were right" & "how little you lost when you were wrong"