When it comes to earnings, 'Analysts are still in La La Land'
"Analysts are still in La La Land," says TheMacroCompass.com founder and CEO Alfonso Peccatiello.
According to FactSet, analysts performing a bottom-up analysis of S&P 500 earnings this year have written down earnings per share (EPS) expectations by 3.8%, from $230.33 to $221.50.
But this may only be the beginning of an earnings re-rating cycle to the downside.
"I expect earnings to drop 15% to 20% from where we stand today," says Peccatiello.
Peccatiello is quick to point out that such a drop would be consistent with — if not slightly below — the median 29% earnings decline experienced during the recessions of the last five decades.
Matt Maley, managing director and equity strategist at Miller Tabak, points out that top-down estimates for the same S&P 500 earnings are pointing to $200 per share — which is about 10% down from the aforementioned bottom-up consensus of $221.50 per share.
Malley finds S&P 500 valuations very hard to believe at 18 times forward earnings.
"I'm sorry, but 18 times earnings is not something we have unless you're getting outsized zero interest rates or outsized QE programs," he says, noting that the forward value of the S&P 500 dropped below 15 in every recession since World War II.
"[I]f earnings are going to have to come down, [stocks have] further to fall," says Maley.
Source: Yahoo Finance