Why Jefferies Downgraded Nomura And Daiwa By Shuli Ren
Japan’s two major brokerages Nomura Holdings (8604.Japan) and Daiwa Securities (8601.Japan) are sliding for the third consecutive day after Britain voted to leave the European Union, down 3.9% and 6.3% respectively.
Investors are worried that Brexit would force Nomura and Daiwa to move their London operations to continental Europe, thereby incurring a lot of relocation costs.
Nomura has more than
2,500 employees in London, while Daiwa has about
400 employees. Both brokerages expanded into London in the past to help large Japanese companies raise funding in Europe.
Over the weekend, Jefferies downgraded Nomura and Daiwa by one notch to Sell and Hold respectively. Analyst Makarim Salman sees both houses to have
fewer debt and equity raising deals, exacerbated by Brexit, and the two brokers do not have much room to cut costs further.
But Jefferies’ downgrade was more than just because of Brexit. In the case of Nomura, it is an expensive stock. Specifically, Jefferies estimates Nomura can clock in only 4.9% return on equity this fiscal year, but it traded (as of Friday) at 10.4 times forward earnings. That is expensive considering JP Morgan (JPM) traded at 10.9 times with higher 6.3% return on equity. Goldman Sachs (GS) has 7.9% return on equity and traded at only 10.1 times earnings (as of Friday).
Jefferies has a Hold rating on Daiwa because its valuation is fair next to Goldman’s. It trades at 10.4 times forward earnings on 7.2% return on equity.
Jefferies now has 310 yen price target for Nomura, implying 0.4 times book, and 600 yen price target for Daiwa, implying 0.78 times book.
Source: Barron's Asia
http://blogs.barrons.com/asiastocks/201 ... and-daiwa/
It's all about "how much you made when you were right" & "how little you lost when you were wrong"