Will European Banks and ist financial system be next ? Fortis has already announced its plan to be merged.
European banks
While Rome burns
Sep 25th 2008
From The Economist print editionAre European banks insulated from the panic in America?
AMERICAN plans to buy up assets that are clogging the financial system lack detail but no one doubts that a massive government intervention is coming. In Europe jittery investors have no such reassurance. European governments have yet to respond publicly to calls from Hank Paulson, the treasury secretary, to follow his lead. They look set to keep faith with the approach that they have used to handle the crisis so far—staving off liquidity worries by allowing banks to use facilities at central banks to swap their assets in exchange for ready cash.
That makes many watchers nervous. The crisis in America has dramatically grown from one of liquidity to one of solvency as well. Lehman Brothers had access to the Federal Reserve’s discount window, after all, but still went under. The burning question now is whether banks have enough capital. On some measures, European banks look pretty well capitalised. The average tier-one ratio, which measures capital based on the riskiness of bank assets, stood at 8% in the first half of the year. That looks solid enough, if you assume that banks have a good handle on risk.
Sceptics on that point prefer to look at European banks’ leverage ratios, which measure the amount of capital banks hold relative to total assets. By some estimates, Deutsche Bank, Barclays and UBS have leverage ratios of 1.2%, 2.4% and 2.1% respectively, which would make broker-dealers weep with fear. Get the risk calculations wrong (it can happen) and the cushion of capital looks horribly thin.
There is plenty of scope for further hits. European vulnerability to insurers of structured credit became clearer with the rescue of American International Group, an insurer that wrote more than $300 billion of protection on assets held by banks in Europe and America. The monoline bond insurers still have lots of potential to cause trouble. Many worry that even now, big losses are yet to be declared. “Lift up the bonnet of a bank in Germany, say, and you often find a steaming wreck inside,†says one bank boss. Reports that KfW, a state-owned bank in Germany, merrily transferred €300m ($426m) to Lehman in a failed swap deal on the day it went bust will not calm nerves.
America’s bail-out plan could even accelerate the pace of write-downs on structured credit if it sets a price below today’s European valuations for nasty assets. And if the price is at or above current marks, which seems likelier, the plan risks creating a nasty dividing-line between European banks that have access to the facility because they have enough American business, and those banks that do not. Behemoths like Barclays, Deutsche and UBS may reasonably expect to find some shelter under Mr Paulson’s tarpaulin. That is far less likely for an institution such as Fortis, a large Belgo-Dutch bank which saw its shares plunge this week.
Strains on capital will also intensify if European economies stall more severely than expected. The rates of deterioration in certain markets are striking. Bank of Ireland issued a starkly gloomy trading statement on September 17th, forecasting rising loan losses and cutting its dividend by half. In Spain the poorly diversified savings banks are warning that non-performing loans could rise sixfold from their levels in mid-2007. In Denmark the central bank felt obliged to bail out a small lender on September 22nd.
Funding pressures are tightening the vice. Lending between banks remains stifled, and demand for central-bank liquidity is consequently extremely high. The European Central Bank’s auction of three-month loans on September 24th was more than three times oversubscribed.
What is more, about $1.4 trillion of bank debt falls due in Europe this year and next, just as bondholders have received their first big blow of the crisis thanks to Lehman’s demise. Worries about how HBOS, a British bank, would roll over its wholesale obligations forced it into the arms of Lloyds TSB on September 17th. Other banks, notably in Spain, Iceland and Scandinavia, are even more dependent on the wholesale markets. The ECB plans to impose stricter conditions on its lending in February but that will be difficult while confidence remains low. Mr Paulson may yet have some imitators across the pond.