by millionairemind » Thu Jul 03, 2008 2:45 pm
Will Trichet drive the world over a cliff?
Wednesday, July 2, 2008, 04:41 PM GMT [General]
Sadly, we are witnessing the sort of strategic errors that turned the recession of 1930 into a global catastrophe.
The European Central Bank is now hell-bent on a course of action that will have a knock-on effect across the world and risk a dangerous implosion of the credit system.
The ECB's Jean-Claude Trichet told Die Zeit today that "there is a risk of inflation exploding."
Let me put it differently: there is a grave risk of social and political disorder "exploding" if the logic of his argument is followed to its grim conclusion, that is to say if the ECB charges ahead with a string of rate rises through the autumn after its near certain move to 4.25 per cent on Thursday.
The ECB mantra is that Europe and the world is on the cusp of a wage-price spiral along the lines of the 1970s. This directly contradicts Ben Bernanke at the Fed, who insists -- correctly -- that today's conditions are not remotely like the 1970s.
(Perhaps this is uncivil, but I might add that Bernanke is one of the greatest economists of our age. Trichet studied political administration at ENA. He is a fine and honourable man, but he is a politician, not an economic historian)
By taking this militant 1970s line, he is in effect kicking Bernanke in the teeth. Or put another way, the ECB is trying to pressure America into a tighter monetary stance. Regrettably, this has in part succeeded. The Fed badly needs to cut rates further -- probably to 1per cent. It cannot do so because the ECB keeps threatening to pull the plug on the dollar.
This is madness. It is the mirror image of the early 1930s, when the Federal Reserve (cowed by the Chicago liquidationists) precipitated the collapse of 4,000 banks, and transmitted their fervour to rest of the world through the Gold Standard. This time there is no Gold Standard. But the globalised capital and currency markets -- egged on by Trichet -- are playing much the same role.
Yes, eurozone inflation reached 4 per cent in June. But what on earth does that tell us, unless you are an inflation-target totemist? It takes two years or so for the full effects of monetary policy to work through the economy, and by then Europe will be an entirely different place.
The ECB was too loose in the early part of this decade (in order to help Germany), keeping rates at 2 per cent until December 2005. That is the underlying cause of the rapid credit growth in the eurozone up to the onset of the credit crunch, and a key cause of silly property bubbles in Club Med and Ireland. The ECB was negligent in 2004, 2005, and 2006, (as were the US Federal Reserve and the Bank of England -- this is not to absolve Anglo-Saxon central banks at all. They all botched royally.)
We are now in the eye of the post-bubble, debt-deleveraging, deflation storm. The ECB's rate rise tomorrow will do nothing whatever to deal with the current oil and food spike, which is in any case causing a dramatic squeeze in real wages. It will merely make the downturn worse. I suspect that the ECB will be cutting frantically to undo the damage from its own ideological excesses soon enough, just as the Fed had to do after its fatal rate rise to 5.25 per cent last year.
For once I find myself in total agreement with France's Nicolas Sarkozy, who said the EBC rise was "at best pointless, at worst counter-productive." This is now plain to anybody who steps outside the Frankfurt Eurotower and takes the pulse of the -- collapsing -- credit and equity markets.
If the rate rise pushes the euro higher against the dollar, it will merely push oil higher as well -- since oil is trading as inverse dollar with seven times leverage. Eurozone "inflation" -- that treacherous term -- will get worse. Brilliant.
Ben Bernanke -- despite his own "helicopter" baggage -- has had the courage to ignore the shrieking punditocracy and slash rates by 325 basis points, looking beyond the oil spike to the deflationary risks that lie beyond. This is statesmanship of the first order.
The ECB is showing the signs of its immaturity. Still an untested institution -- determined to prove itself the worthy successor of the Bundesbank -- it seems to lack the self-confidence to think outside the box and respond creatively to a fast-changing world. It is playing rigidly by a rule-book written long ago, for a provincial bank, in a world that has disappeared.
The Bundesbank evolved in the 1950s and 1960s to serve a corporatist economy that bears no resemblance to today's Europe. It made plenty of mistakes along the way, not least by getting into a pitched-battle with the Fed and raising rates in October 1987, precipitating the global stock market crash. It then had to slash rates three times in short order to cope with consequences.
Perhaps Germany now needs higher rates as unemployment tumbles to a 16-year low. It has gained 30 per cent to 40 per cent in unit labour competitiveness against Italy and Spain since the currencies were fixed, and 20 per cent against France.
It is conquering market share across Club Med. As chief supplier to booming Russia, it is enjoying a (positive) asymmetric shock. But Germany is not the euro-zone.
The unspoken truth -- and now the source of so much poisonous policy-making -- is that Europe signed an implicit political contract with Germany in the 1990s that monetary union should never lead to a recurrence of German inflation. The euro must be as hard as the old D-Mark, and not a Lira-Peseta.
The system is now being bent to comply with this contract. Indeed, one senses that Buba chief Axel Weber has a near maniacal urge to press the point, like Shylock cutting his `Pound of Flesh', -- even if such a course of action has become inherently destructive, especially for Germany's strategic interests.
Let him read `Nathan Der Weise' by his great countryman Gotthold Ephraim Lessing, set in the Third Crusade.
As the BIS and others have warned, the eurozone is already in the grip of an incipient credit crunch. Distressed companies are drawing down existing loans from banks because the securitisation market is shut.
The result of monetary overkill is already evident in parts of system. Ireland's GDP contracted at an annual rate of 1.5 per cent in the first quarter. It will get a lot worse. Investment fell 19.1 per cent. House prices have fallen for fifteen months in a row.
Spain's house prices have fallen 6.2 per cent since July (4.3 per cent this year alone) according to Facilisimo.com. This hardly surprising. Euribor used to price floating rate mortgages (98 per cent of the total in Spain) has risen 120 basis points since the crunch began.
Unemployment has risen by 425,000 over the last year, a faster rate of increase than during the recession of the early 1990s. Monetary policy has been tightened into a severe downturn.
HSBC expects French house prices to fall 10 per cent over the course of this year and next.
Yes, inflation has run amok in Asia, the Mid-East, and Russia. They will have to slam on the brakes. Some are doing so already. This will hit just as the effects of the ECB's squeeze bites harder.
It has become fashionable to talk of "global inflation". There is no such thing. A large number of countries have let their money supplies surge out control by refusing to let their currencies revalue against the dollar. They are now paying the price.
The Western states with collapsing property and asset markets (the Anglo-Saxons, Club Med) or demographic implosions (Germany) have the opposite problem. Confusing one with the other will take us straight into a slump.
"If a speculator is correct half of the time, he is hitting a good average. Even being right 3 or 4 times out of 10 should yield a person a fortune if he has the sense to cut his losses quickly on the ventures where he has been wrong" - Bernard Baruch
Disclaimer - The author may at times own some of the stocks mentioned in this forum. All discussions are NOT to be construed as buy/sell recommendations. Readers are advised to do their own research and analysis.