by winston » Sun Jan 25, 2009 7:18 pm
20090115 Macquarie China High Speed
China decoupling...in wind
We review the operations of China High Speed Transmission (CHST) amid a deteriorating global credit market, and upon transfer of coverage to Carol Cao. We adjust our target price from HK$17.40 to HK$11.30 based on a lower target PER of 17x on FY09E earnings. We maintain our Outperform rating on CHST given the 32% potential upside from the current price.
2009 – a tough year for wind, but China growth intact
With tighter credit conditions and weaker global economic growth, we think that 2009 will be a tough year for the wind industry in the EU and the US, where project delays will likely be common due to the unavailability and higher cost of financing. We believe, however, that the growth of China’s wind industry will remain largely unabated due to strong government policy support, the declining cost of project funding, and stable wind tariff despite falling fossil fuel prices.
Domestic focus and pricing discount mitigate wind risks
The main risk to CHST’s earnings in 2009, in our view, is the potential delay or cancellation of orders from its international wind gearbox customers in the event of a delay or cancellation of wind turbine delivery. We estimate that CHST sells about half of its wind gearboxes to international customers, with GE being the largest customer, making up 40% of its wind gearbox sales in FY09E. We believe that such risk is largely mitigated for CHST, due mainly to its pricing discount over international competitors, as well as the secure demand from its domestic customer base. The biggest risk is with Nordex, the German wind turbine marker, which makes up about 10% of CHST’s wind sales.
Decline in raw material prices to help maintain margins
Weaker demand for wind turbines worldwide could intensify competition amongst the component suppliers and place downside pressure on gearbox prices. Marketing and advertising costs associated with the expected relief in the supply bottleneck of wind gearboxes could also increase. However, we believe that the expected decline in raw material prices in 2009 will help CHST maintain margins.
Healthy balance sheet to fund growth
We believe CHST has a strong enough balance sheet to fund its future expansion. We expect CHST to turn positive free cashflow in FY10. While there could be potential losses related to the equity swap that CHST currently holds, the downside risk is limited and already well known to the market, in our view.
TP downgrade due mainly to global wind de-rating
The downgrade to our target price for CHST is the result of benchmarking to the global wind sector valuation, which has been de-rated in recent months. We have also lowered our FY09E earnings by 9% based on more-conservative assumptions for non-wind sales. Our target price is currently based on a 17x FY09E PER (24x FY09E PER previously), which is at a premium to the global wind industry average of 10.3x, but on a par with the current valuation of global wind gearbox suppliers such as Hansen Transmission (HSN LN, GBp1.44, NR).
It's all about "how much you made when you were right" & "how little you lost when you were wrong"