by winston » Fri Jan 15, 2010 12:21 pm
Not vested. CPO Prices higher means less margins, if they are not able to pass on the cost. The Chinese govt did freeze prices a few years ago. No EPS Growth @ PE 17.
From Kim Eng:-
Wilmar – Company Update (Rohan Suppiah, DID: 64321455)
Previous Day Closing price: $7.04
Recommendation: BUY (maintained)
Target price: $8.10 (raised from $7.50)
Thriving on volatility
We are raising Wilmar’s net profit forecast for FY10 by 5% to US$1,871m, on the back of stronger CPO prices. Wilmar does not directly benefit from higher CPO prices, as it is a net buyer of CPO to supply its massive downstream operations; however, as the largest market buyer of CPO, Wilmar has always done well when CPO prices are volatile, through its dominant presence and insight in the edible oils market.
CPO prices trending up
Our revised FY10 numbers factor in higher turnover but reduced margins. CPO prices have risen by over 40% over the last 3 months on anticipation of stronger demand as economies emerge from the economic crisis, notably China. The demand-driven recovery will also allow Wilmar to sustain or raise its average selling prices across all segments.
Commodities recovery a catalyst
We believe that there is potential for more upside as the broader commodities cycle is on an upturn. CPO prices have also risen in tandem with crude oil, which sets a baseline for CPO prices as a biofuel source. This could prove to be a strong catalyst for Wilmar’s stock price outperformance.
( Not Logical. If CPO is going up, margins will be affected if they cant raise prices. Can they raise prices ? Will the Chinese government allow them to raise prices ? )
China listing can be revived
Wilmar is also likely to revive its plans to list its China businesses in Hong Kong in the coming months, as market conditions have improved. A high multiple for its China businesses is justifiable due to its ability to leverage and replicate its current edible oils distribution network into several other consumer staples such as rice and flour.
( When it was their turn to list in HK, the market conditions were very good. Nothing has changed and this cant be a catalyst ).
Currently, comparables such as China-Agri and China Foods are trading at between 20x to 24x FY10 earnings. We peg its potential listing multiple at 21x, without yet factoring the new businesses to our earnings forecasts.
SOTP valuation at S$8.10 - maintain BUY
Our new FY10 net profit forecast implies a 9% rise over FY09, excluding 3Q09’s one-time gain of US$167m for the sale of new shares of Wilmar China to members of the Kuok Group. This is also a healthy 10% 3-year CAGR to 2011.
We are shifting our valuation multiple to FY10 earnings, and ascribe a blended PER multiple of 21x for Wilmar China and 19x for its non-China business. This yields a new target price of S$8.10, up from S$7.50 previously. Maintain Buy.
It's all about "how much you made when you were right" & "how little you lost when you were wrong"