vested
ASIA STOCKS TO WATCH Why Standard Chartered Shares Tanked Today
By Isabella Zhong
While StanChart’s earnings were a respectable 6% higher than analyst expectations, its performance fell short of the mark set by rival HSBC (5.HK) last week.
Here’s Northern Trust Capital Markets’ head of Asia research Douglas Morton with more:
Unlike HSBC results last week which beat consensus by 12%, Standard Chartered results have come in with a 6% beat (similarly helped by stable NIMS and lower impairments as was HSBC) but without the increased cash disbursement announced by HSBC’s additional buyback.
Indeed Standard Chartered declared no interim dividend and that and end of year dividend will only be “considered”, which may disappoint some following HSBC’s results on Monday.
ROE recovered substantially from 2.1% last year to 5.2%, but still well below HSBC’s announced 8.8% and with little chance of further improvement in the years ahead in our opinion.
The disappointment for Standard Chartered came in the form of flat revenue (driven by flat QoQ loan growth, below expectations), underlining the potential lack of growth prospects for the Emerging Markets focused bank when compared to HSBC.
Company commentary further underlined this point in our opinion, painting a starkly different outlook when compared to HSBC’s excitement surrounding their Asian prospects (and in particular their OBOR exposure) as announced on Monday.
StanChart also trails HSBC on Asia profitability.
HSBC also paid a 5.6% dividend yield last year, while StanChart didn’t pay a dividend.
StanChart shares have gained 32% this year and trade at 16 times forward earnings, which is higher than HSBC’s 15 times.
Source: Barron's Asia
http://www.barrons.com/articles/why-sta ... 1501747145