by winston » Fri Aug 05, 2016 11:09 am
not vested
New report: Solid operations with attractive valuation EPS
We upgrade NagaCorp to OUTPERFORM (from Neutral) for its faster-than-peers growth momentum but undemanding valuation.
NagaCorp is trading at only 5x 2017 EV/EBITDA (below its historical avg of 6x) at a 60% discount to Macau (vs avg. 50%).
In VIP segment, despite the lower junket commission rate from 1 January, VIP growth remains robust (rolling +65% YoY in 1Q16),
suggesting the built up of traction with junket/players.
In massmarket, the growth trend has been solid (table buy-ins/EGM billsin +15%/32% YoY in 1Q16) thanks to improving traffic and
constant business optimisation of the floor.
We expect the solid growth to continue owing to:
(1) NagaCity Walk opening by August;
(2) improving accessibility to NagaWorld by Bassaka Air; and
(3) better player mix—Chinese visitations have been persistently growing at a faster pace.
We see upside risks to earnings from:
(1) the renewal of EGM operation contract;
(2) commencement of tele-betting; and
(3) nongaming revenue income from NagaCity Walk.
Its solid operation and potential earnings upgrade are likely to serve as re-rating catalysts.
VIP volume growth remain robust despite lower commission
Despite the scale back of junket commission from >70% of VIP GGR to a maximum of 70% since 1 January 2016, the VIP rolling chips
continued to grow robustly at 65% YoY in 1Q16 (2015: +27%).
On top of the junket events around the Chinese New Year and lower house luck, we believe this also suggests improving traction with junket/players.
As the business ramps up, the growth momentum is set to normalise. Yet, with a more accommodative regulation and junket commission scheme, we believe Naga could sustain a better-than-peers’ growth.
Solid growth to continue in 2H16, especially for mass-market
Aside from VIP, the constant optimisation of casino floor (e.g., allowing table buys-in and implement EGM TITO system) have been well received by players.
We forecast mass tables buy-ins could sustain its steady growth at 16% in 1H16 and EGM bills-in will show a +23% YoY growth.
The solid momentum is set to continue owing to:
(1) NagaCity Walk opening by August,
(2) improving accessibility as Bassaka Air expands coverage and frequency; and
(3) improving players mix, whereas the Chinese visitations, who are usually more serious gamblers, have been persistently growing at a faster pace.
Widened valuation discount against Macau appears unjustified; Upgrade to OUTPERFORM
Factoring in the potential EGM income, solid operating trend, and the CB conversion for Naga2, we revise our 2016-18E EPS by 18%/13%/-2% and raise our TP to HK$6.5 (from HK$5.2).
This is based on:
(1) 6.5x 2017 EBITDA on NagaWorld (a 50% discount to Macau, consistent with the historical average) and
(2) a DCF-value of HK$1.0/sh for Naga2.
Trading at only 5.2x 2017 EBITDA (vs the historical 6.1x) and at a 60% discount to Macau's 13.3x but with better operating trends, the widened valuation discount against Macau appears unjustified.
Source: CS
It's all about "how much you made when you were right" & "how little you lost when you were wrong"