Not vested. From OCBC:-
Noble Group Ltd: Value emerging
Still fundamentally strong. Shares of Noble Group Ltd (Noble) fell by 7.2% over the past week, underperforming the STI’s 5.9% decline. While weak sentiment surrounding the stock could be attributed to declining oil and commodity prices as well as fears of softening demand for commodities, Noble’s fundamentals remain unchanged. Its business model is volumedriven,
not price-driven. It is almost completely shielded from commodity price fluctuations with 96% of its inventories hedged. Meanwhile, the group has successfully expanded its volume with 1H08 tonnage growing 32% YoY, and management is confident that volumes will continue growing on sustainable demand for commodities, especially from developing countries.
Trading at steep discount to peer. Having fallen 30% since the start of the year, Noble is now trading at 7xFY08 PER. This comes in at the lower range of its 6-year historical trading band, which swung from a low of 5.6x during the post-SARS period in 2004 to a high of 21x last year. Its SGXlisted peer, Olam Int’l Ltd, is trading at 16.9x consensus PER despite posting
a smaller 53.8% growth in FY08 (June YE) earnings to S$167.7m. In comparison, Noble is commanding just 6.4x FY09 PER (Dec YE) despite posting a 194% YoY surge in 1H08 profits to US$291.1m. Given Noble’s larger earnings base and exposure to a wider variety of asset classes, the steep 62% discount is not warranted.
Enhancing its supply chain. Noble has recently invested in a grain and sugar export terminal in Brazil. While this investment is not expected to be earnings accretive, we believe that it will give the group greater control over its supply chain logistics and enhance operational efficiency, ultimately allowing it to extract more value from its supply chain operations. To recap, Noble doubled its gross profit per ton (GP/ton) in 1H08 by increasing its ownership of low cost assets. Further investments such as these will help to boost its GP/ton further.
On track to surpass estimates. Noble’s 1H08 earnings have already met 64% of our FY08 earnings estimates, putting the group on track to surpass our forecast. Lower commodity prices will ease working capital requirements on the group in 2H08. We ease our valuation parameter to the stock’s 6-year average PER of 12x (from 14x), and based on its blended FY08/09 earnings, derive a fair value estimate of S$2.53 (previously $2.99). This still represents an attractive 80% upside. As such, we maintain our BUY rating on Noble. (Lee Wen Ching)

